For my respected challenge I reviewed Joseph Powell’s review of “Boys and Girls: Superheroes in the Doll Conrer Vivian Gussin Paley”. I chose this article because it referenced what we had discussed in our last class in regards to why boys are more likely than girls to be comic book purchasers and it talked about , “ boys and girls in their respected roles as superheroes and homemakers” ( Powell 218).In comic books, or at least the majority of them, girls are more submissive than boys. It is the boys that take action and the girls who just watch it happen. He talked about their dynamics and why they choose their respected roles. Society ,thus, has us think we have to be something even though we’re not.
He states that it happens when were really young. Boys take the more assertive roles of robbers, and girls are the ones being robbed. I think that just goes to show the reason why boys are more so at a young age able to relate to being a superhero and get into reading comic books. Girls don’t see themselves in these comic books and don’t start reading them when their young. By the time their older they are to set in their ways and not as patient at trying to get to understand the comic book. Therefore, I think this was a good article because it illuminates the reason why girls can not and are not such big fans of comic books. Society tells them it is not their place. Which is really sad, and unless the comic book world can change that, it could be the set thought that brings the comic book industry to its knees.
He states that it happens when were really young. Boys take the more assertive roles of robbers, and girls are the ones being robbed. I think that just goes to show the reason why boys are more so at a young age able to relate to being a superhero and get into reading comic books. Girls don’t see themselves in these comic books and don’t start reading them when their young. By the time their older they are to set in their ways and not as patient at trying to get to understand the comic book. Therefore, I think this was a good article because it illuminates the reason why girls can not and are not such big fans of comic books. Society tells them it is not their place. Which is really sad, and unless the comic book world can change that, it could be the set thought that brings the comic book industry to its knees.
In addition, I have a few suggestions in ways the comic book world can make their industry a more female friendly environment. First, I'd like to have many more female heroines. They are so out numbered by male heroes, and I feel a lot of the better writers out there are more hesistant to write for them. In order for girls to want to buy comics, they are going to have to want to emulate the characters in them and with the type of female heroines currently out there I can see why they hesistate. Secondly, the stores have to be set up in a way that is easier for girls to understand the organization. Girls like organization something many comic book stores never tend to have. Why not have like a small brochure explaining to them how everything is laid out so they don't accidently open a comic book that will forever turn them off. Thirdly, come on gentlemen help a girl out? I think the employees at the store have to be willing to walk up to a girl and ask them if they need help with something. So many times comic book employees just sit behind their register not really doing anything. They should be more proactive.
Powell, Jerry. Winterthur Portfolio. 2/3 ed. Vol. 21. N.p.: University of Chicago, n.d. 218-19.
JSTOR. Web. 15 Dec. 2010. <http://www.jstor.org/stable/1181085>.
Jacqueline,
ReplyDeleteWhat a great topic to write about for the challenge. So what do you think about kids growing up and how they are molded? I really liked what you had to say in that I do believe that society does play a huge role in what we are and are not expected to do and say. But, in my own personal experience I'm really on the fence on this one. For example, I was raised as an only child with only my imagination to keep me busy. I spent much of my time with my dad, ok maybe my dad may have played a role in this one... but I was a full on tomboy (and to some extent still am). I loved playing with my male cousin Michael, and we would fight, play with the little green soldiers, blow up Hot wheel cars and "rob banks". I never got "robbed". I wouldn't allow it. Yes , I also had Barbie dolls and played dress up once in awhile, but it never gave me the rush that I felt when I would play hide and seek with fully loaded semi automatic Super Soaker water guns! I don't know too many girls, ok, I don't know ANY girls that did that when they were growing up. I was a total boy's girl and I really enjoyed it. I still love those elements today. I can walk into a Toys R' Us and go straight to the boys section and be totally ecstatic. Looking across the way at the pink Barbie section, just doesn't really do it for me. What fun is that? Dresses and plastic dolls that don't have "ninja" grips. Yeah, I'm not interested. But! What does that say about me? Maybe my dad influenced me, I don't know. I can't tell really, but I sure would like to know. Do you know what I am trying to say? Maybe you can relate, I don't know. But, I strongly think that there is an innate desire to behave a certain way regardless of how you were raised etc. Maybe not to such a large degree, but the genes definitely play a role. Great topic to bring up and read about. Tell me, what are your thoughts? Did you play with Super Soakers? Those were so much fun!
Lol. Yeah I did play with super soakers and I was a tomboy growing up too. However, I definitely think were exceptions to the rule. I really do think society promotes boys to be one way and girls to be an other. We were just lucky to escape.
ReplyDeleteStill on the fence here regarding the nature versus nurture question! Deserves attention...!
ReplyDelete